What happens if you lose an Employment Tribunal?

Facing a dispute before an employment tribunal can be a distressing experience, filled with uncertainty and anxiety. Losing a case means more than just a legal setback; it can lead to significant financial and professional consequences that affect your future career prospects. An employment tribunal is a specialized body that resolves conflicts between employers and employees, particularly in cases of dismissal, discrimination, or unpaid wages. Given these high stakes, it is essential to have an experienced employment law solicitor by your side: their expertise will help you better understand your rights, and minimise risks related to your specific situation.

Discover how to protect your professional future even after an unfavourable employment tribunal decision.

Do you need a solicitor?

We will connect you with the right solicitor, near you.

Find a solicitor near me Request a call

Will you have to pay the other side’s costs if you lose?

Understanding employment tribunal costs if you lose is crucial for anyone facing tribunal proceedings, as financial liability can significantly impact your decision-making.

Standard cost rules

Unlike other civil courts, employment tribunal costs if you lose are generally limited in the UK. Employment tribunals typically operate under a “no costs” rule, meaning the losing party doesn’t automatically pay the winner’s legal expenses. This protection encourages workers to pursue legitimate claims without fear of devastating financial consequences.

When you might face cost orders

Employment tribunal costs if you lose can become significant in specific circumstances:

• Vexatious or unreasonable conduct: If the tribunal finds your case was brought vexatiously, abusively, or disruptively, you may face a costs order covering the other party’s reasonable expenses.
• No reasonable prospect of success: Claims with no reasonable prospect of success that should never have been brought can result in cost liability, particularly if you ignored clear employment tribunal legal advice.
• Unreasonable conduct during proceedings: Failing to comply with orders, causing unnecessary delays, or behaving unreasonably during the process can trigger cost consequences.

What costs might you pay?

When employment tribunal costs if you lose do apply, they typically include:

• Lost earnings for attending hearings.
• Administrative fees and tribunal expenses.
• Witness expenses and reasonable preparation costs.
• Representation costs (capped at £20,000 for most cases).

What impact does losing at an employment tribunal have on your career?

Employment tribunal lose outcomes create legitimate concerns about future career prospects, though the impact varies significantly depending on your industry and circumstances.

Public nature of decisions

Employment tribunal what happens includes publication of decisions, as tribunal judgments become part of public record. However, this doesn’t mean automatic career damage:

• Not criminal convictions: Employment tribunal decisions are civil judgments, not criminal convictions, and don’t appear on standard background checks or criminal records.
• Limited visibility: While decisions are public, they’re not actively publicised and may not come to most employers’ attention unless specifically searched.

Professional reputation considerations

Employment tribunal lose outcomes can affect your professional standing in several ways:

• Industry-specific impact: In closely-knit industries or specialised sectors, tribunal decisions may become known among potential employers, particularly if the case received media attention.
• Reference implications: Former employers may reference tribunal proceedings in employment references, though they must be factual and non-defamatory in their comments.
• Trust and perception issues: Some employers might view involvement in tribunal proceedings negatively, regardless of merit, affecting future opportunities.

Can you appeal an employment tribunal’s decision?

Employment tribunal lose decisions aren’t necessarily final. The employment tribunal appeal process provides opportunities to challenge unfavourable outcomes in specific circumstances.

Grounds for employment tribunal appeal

Employment tribunal appeal options are limited to legal errors rather than disagreements with factual findings:

• Errors of law: The tribunal misunderstood or misapplied relevant legal principles, statutes, or case law.
• Procedural irregularities: Serious procedural errors that affected the fairness of proceedings, such as bias or failure to follow proper procedures.
• Perverse decisions: In exceptional cases where no reasonable tribunal could have reached the same conclusion based on the evidence presented.

Employment tribunal appeal process

Employment tribunal appeal proceedings involve strict requirements and deadlines:

• Time limits: Appeals must be filed within 42 days of receiving the written judgment, with very limited exceptions for extensions.
• Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT): Appeals go to the EAT, a higher specialised court that reviews tribunal decisions for legal errors.
• Permission requirements: Some appeals require permission to proceed, adding another hurdle to the process.

Risks of employment tribunal appeal

Employment tribunal appeal proceedings carry significant risks that must be carefully considered:

• Cost exposure: Appeal proceedings can result in substantial employment tribunal costs if you lose, particularly if the EAT finds your appeal was misconceived or abusive.
• Time and stress: Appeals typically take 6-12 months and require substantial time and emotional investment with no guarantee of success.
• Worsened outcomes: In rare cases, appeals can result in outcomes worse than the original decision if new legal issues emerge.

How to reduce damage and protect your rights after an employment tribunal decision?

Facing an unfavourable employment tribunal decision is challenging, but strategic actions can limit impacts and safeguard your interests.

Act quickly to manage the situation better:

• Get immediate employment tribunal legal advice to understand your specific case consequences.
• Analsze the decision to identify potential grounds for employment tribunal appeal and available options.
• Communicate in a measured and professional way with your employer and any other concerned parties.

Prevent excessive costs:

• Assess financial risks before challenging decisions or starting new procedures.
• Avoid legal steps without advice. A solicitor will help prevent unnecessary employment tribunal costs if you lose.
• Explore alternatives to court, such as mediation, to resolve disputes at lower cost.

Protect your professional reputation:

• Be transparent with future employers without oversharing details about tribunal proceedings.
• Highlight your willingness to learn from the experience and improve professionally.
• Continue developing your skills and network to demonstrate ongoing value and bounce back quickly.

FAQs

1. How long does an employment tribunal procedure usually take? The average duration often ranges from 6-12 months, depending on case complexity and tribunal availability. Additional delays may occur due to evidence exchanges, witness scheduling, or postponement requests.
2. Can disputes be settled before the hearing? Yes, most disputes settle through ACAS early conciliation or direct negotiation. Settlement avoids the uncertainty, costs, and stress of a full tribunal hearing while providing guaranteed outcomes.
3. What types of compensation can be awarded? Tribunals award compensation for unfair dismissal (basic and compensatory awards), discrimination (including injury to feelings), unpaid wages, and notice pay. Awards cover financial losses and, in discrimination cases, emotional distress.

Understanding employment tribunal what happens when you lose is crucial for protecting your career and financial future. Whether facing initial proceedings, considering employment tribunal appeal, or managing the aftermath of an unfavorable decision, professional legal guidance makes the difference between devastating consequences and manageable outcomes.

Need employment tribunal legal advice?

Qredible’s network of specialist employment solicitors provides expert guidance on all aspects of tribunal proceedings, from initial case assessment through employment tribunal appeal and beyond.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• Employment tribunal costs if you lose are typically minimal except in cases of vexatious or unreasonable conduct, with cost orders capped at £20,000 for most proceedings.
• While employment tribunal lose outcomes are public, they’re not criminal convictions and career damage can be minimised through strategic reputation management and professional development
• Employment tribunal appeal is possible for legal errors within 42 days, but carries significant cost and time risks that require careful professional assessment before proceeding