Breach of restraining order defences in the UK

They’ve contacted you again. Turned up at your door. Sent another message. Your restraining order means nothing if it isn’t enforced. Or perhaps you’re accused of breaching one; facing police questions, court dates, possible prison. Breach of restraining order defences determine whether someone walks free or faces custody, whether victims gain real protection or endure continued fear. The law gives both sides powerful tools, but only if you know how to use them. Specialist criminal defence solicitors and harassment law experts understand the stakes. Time matters, seek legal help promptly.

Discover how to enforce your restraining order or defend breach allegations.

Do you need a solicitor?

We will connect you with the right solicitor, near you.

Find a solicitor near me Request a call

Common breach of restraining order defences

A restraining order prohibits specific contact or behaviour between individuals, typically issued to protect victims from harassment, stalking, or domestic abuse. When someone’s accused of breaching these terms, several breach of restraining order defences may apply depending on the circumstances:

• Lack of knowledge: The accused genuinely didn’t know the restraining order existed or hadn’t been properly served with the order documents.
• Unintentional contact: The breach occurred accidentally, such as an unavoidable encounter in a shared neighbourhood or workplace, with no deliberate attempt to violate the terms.
• Victim-initiated contact: The protected person initiated or encouraged the contact, though this remains legally complex as the order still binds the accused regardless of the victim’s wishes.
• Reasonable excuse: Emergency situations, such as protecting a child from immediate danger or responding to a genuine crisis involving shared dependents.
• Mistaken identity: Evidence proves the accused wasn’t the person who made contact or committed the alleged breach.
• Order terms unclear: The restraining order’s wording was ambiguous, making it unclear what specific actions were prohibited.

The legal process when a restraining order is breached

Once a breach is reported, the criminal justice system moves quickly; often faster than defendants expect. The process follows a strict pathway that can lead to immediate arrest and prosecution:

• Police investigation: Officers will interview the victim, gather evidence such as messages, CCTV footage, or witness statements, and typically arrest the accused for questioning under caution.
• Charging decision: The Crown Prosecution Service reviews the evidence and decides whether to charge the accused with breaching the order, considering the likelihood of conviction and public interest.
• First court appearance: The defendant appears before magistrates, usually within 24-48 hours of arrest, where they enter a plea and the court considers bail conditions or remand in custody.
• Evidence presentation: The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused knew about the order, committed the prohibited act, and had no reasonable excuse for their actions.
• Sentencing hearing: If convicted, magistrates or a Crown Court judge will impose penalties ranging from fines and community orders to imprisonment of up to five years for serious or repeated breaches.
• Appeal options: Defendants can challenge convictions or sentences through the Crown Court or Court of Appeal if they believe errors occurred during proceedings.

Consequences for the accused: What happens after breach

A conviction for breaching a restraining order carries severe penalties that extend far beyond the courtroom. The consequences affect your liberty, reputation, and future prospects immediately:

• Immediate custody: Courts take breaches seriously. First-time offenders risk up to six months in magistrates’ court, whilst Crown Court can impose sentences up to five years for aggravated or repeated violations.
• Criminal record: A conviction appears on your criminal record permanently, affecting employment prospects, travel visas, professional licenses, and housing applications for years to come.
• Stricter order terms: Courts often extend the restraining order’s duration, widen the exclusion zones, or add stricter conditions that further restrict your movements and activities.
• Bail refusal: If you breach whilst on bail for another offence, magistrates will likely remand you in custody until trial, particularly if they view you as a risk to the victim.
• Enhanced restraining order: Victims can apply for restraining order modifications, including indefinite duration or additional protections that limit your freedom more severely than the original terms.
• Civil consequences: Beyond criminal penalties, victims may pursue civil claims for damages, restraining order costs, or seek injunctions that compound your legal difficulties.

The victim’s perspective: Ensuring your restraining order is respected

Your restraining order only works if you know how to enforce it. Too many victims watch perpetrators ignore court orders whilst feeling helpless, but the law gives you concrete tools to demand compliance:

• Report every breach: Contact police the moment any violation occurs, no matter how minor it seems; patterns of behaviour strengthen prosecution cases and demonstrate ongoing risk to your safety.
• Document everything meticulously: Screenshot messages, save voicemails, photograph the person near your property, note dates and times of encounters, and keep a detailed harassment log that creates irrefutable evidence.
• Request arrest: Police must investigate breaches seriously. If officers seem reluctant, explicitly state you’re reporting a criminal offence and request an incident reference number for accountability.
• Seek order variations: If the current terms prove inadequate, instruct a solicitor to apply for restraining order modifications, including wider exclusion zones, electronic tagging, or indefinite duration to increase protection levels.
• Consider civil remedies: Pursue non-molestation orders or occupation orders through family courts that provide additional layers of protection and different enforcement mechanisms beyond criminal proceedings.
• Engage victim support services: Specialist organisations offer practical advice, court accompaniment, safety planning, and advocacy that ensures your voice is heard throughout the legal process.

FAQs

• What happens if the victim breaks a restraining order UK? Victims cannot breach their own restraining orders; only the accused person has a legal duty to comply. Victim-initiated contact doesn’t create criminal liability for them, though it may reduce sentencing severity for the accused.
• Can the police issue a restraining order? No, only courts issue restraining orders. Police can arrest for breaches and apply for emergency Domestic Violence Protection Orders lasting up to 28 days.
• How much is a restraining order? Restraining orders following criminal proceedings are free. Independent civil applications cost £75-£300 in court fees, though legal aid often covers domestic abuse

Breach of restraining order defences require expert intervention, whether you’re enforcing protection or defending allegations. The stakes involve your safety or liberty, making professional legal guidance essential rather than optional for navigating these complex proceedings successfully.

Don’t face restraining order breaches alone!

Qredible’s network connects you with specialist solicitors who understand the urgency of your situation.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

• Breach of restraining order defences include lack of knowledge, unintentional contact, and reasonable excuse, though even victim-initiated contact doesn’t exempt the accused from prosecution and potential custody.
• Victims must report every breach, document all evidence meticulously, and instruct solicitors to ensure police investigations result in meaningful prosecution rather than warnings.
• Both parties need specialist legal representation; solicitors identify defences, challenge evidence, strengthen enforcement, and navigate court processes that determine liberty and safety.